Tenants’ RTB Claim for $25,350 Dismissed!

This is a successful decision obtained by Henderson & Lee Law Corporation on behalf of a landlord in British Columbia.
In this case, RTB File No. 910156937, the tenants sought more than $25,000 in compensation, alleging that the landlord had unlawfully increased rent over several years without proper notice under the Residential Tenancy Act.
The Rent Payment History
Mr. Chris Wong of Henderson & Lee Law Corporation successfully argued on behalf of the landlord that the tenants had knowingly accepted and paid the adjusted rent for many years without formally disputing the increase.
The RTB accepted the landlord’s position and applied the legal doctrine of “estoppel,” finding that it would be unfair and unreasonable for the tenants to later seek reimbursement after voluntarily paying the rent increase for approximately 54 months.

The Later Agreement and the Outcome
The RTB further accepted the landlord’s argument that a later tenancy agreement signed in 2023, which added an additional occupant and adjusted the rent, constituted a new tenancy agreement rather than an unlawful rent increase.
As a result, the tenants’ entire claim was dismissed without leave to reapply, including their request for reimbursement of filing fees.

What This Case Highlights
This case demonstrates several important principles in residential tenancy disputes: long-term acceptance of rental terms may affect a tenant’s later legal claims; conduct and delay can significantly impact the outcome of a dispute; proper legal strategy and presentation of evidence are critical in defending RTB claims; and a revised tenancy agreement may be treated as a new contractual arrangement depending on the circumstances.
Henderson & Lee Law Corporation is proud to assist landlords, tenants, and property owners throughout British Columbia with residential tenancy disputes, RTB hearings, and housing-related litigation. If you are facing an RTB claim or tenancy dispute, obtaining timely legal advice can make a significant difference to the outcome of your case.
This article is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.


